Application fee manipulations in matching markets
نویسنده
چکیده
In some well-known hospital–intern type of matching markets, hospitals impose mandatory application fees on internship applicants to consider their applications. Motivated by this real-life phenomenon, we study the application fee overreporting incentives of hospitals in centralized matching markets by assuming that interns have finite budgets to spend on such fees. Our main theorem shows that no stable mechanism is immune to application fee manipulations. Interestingly, under any stable rule, hospitals might not only obtain better matchings but also increase their application fee revenues through overreporting their application fees. In the restricted domains in which either side has homogeneous preferences or each hospital has only one available position, every stable mechanism turns out to be immune to application fee overreportings. © 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
منابع مشابه
Incentive Compatibility of Large Centralized Matching Markets
We study the manipulability of stable matching mechanisms. To quantify incentives to manipulate stable mechanisms, we consider markets with random cardinal utilities, which induce ordinal preferences over match partners. We show that most agents in large matching markets are close to being indifferent overall stable matchings. In oneto-one matching, the utility gain by manipulating a stable mec...
متن کاملIT Application in Agricultural Marketing Service Delivery — Electronic Tender System in Regulated Markets*
The application of Information Technology (IT) in the form of introduction of e-tender system in the selected regulated agricultural markets of Karnataka has been found to improve the marketing efficiency through competitive and transparent bidding mechanism, and by minimization of manipulations in trading practices. Besides, a considerable time saving for all the stakeholders has been a clear ...
متن کاملMatching intermediaries for information goods in the presence of direct search: an examination of switching costs and obsolescence of information
This paper investigates patterns of revenues earned by an intermediary that matches buyers and sellers in the presence of direct search markets. We develop a theoretical structure and a computer simulation model of such a marketplace where vendors are horizontally differentiated, and an intermediary matches clients to the optimal vendor for a fee. The model is applicable to information services...
متن کاملDynamic Matching Markets and the Deferred Acceptance Mechanism
Many matching markets are dynamic, with one side’s priorities often depending on previous allocations. This creates opportunities for manipulations that do not exist in static matching problems. The school-choice problem, for example, exhibits considerable student mobility and a priority system that favors incumbent students and their siblings. In such a dynamic environment, parents can manipul...
متن کاملBrokers¬タル contractual arrangements in the Manhattan residential rental market ¬リニ
We bring new evidence to bear on the role of intermediaries in frictional matching markets and on how parties design contracts with them. Specifically, we examine two features of contracts between landlords and agents in the Manhattan residential rental market. In our data, 72 percent of listings involve exclusive relationships between landlords and agents (the remaining 28 percent are non-excl...
متن کامل